By Marc Darrow, MD, JD
A person writes: “I have hip osteoarthritis classified as severe, and the pain is starting to move to the knee.” It sounds as though the arthritis is spreading. That description, however, does not tell us whether the knee pain is referred from the hip, caused by a knee problem, or associated with a change in walking.
This question came up during a recent Living Pain-Free radio discussion. Dr. Darrow emphasized identifying the pain generator—the structure or process contributing to symptoms—rather than making a treatment decision from an imaging label alone.
That principle works in both directions. Hip arthritis should not be assumed to explain every pain in the leg. It should also not be dismissed when a person mainly reports knee pain.
Can hip arthritis cause knee pain?
Yes. Hip disease can produce pain felt at the knee. In a published series, 21 patients referred for knee pain were ultimately found to have hip pathology contributing to their symptoms. Twelve had previously undergone knee surgery with little or no relief. Seventeen subsequently underwent hip replacement, and 14 reported complete resolution of knee pain. This was a selected case series, not an estimate of how often knee pain comes from the hip. (1)
The series illustrates why examining the hip can matter even when the knee is the main complaint. It also shows that hip replacement can be helpful when the hip is correctly identified as the source. A discussion of diagnostic uncertainty should not become a blanket argument against surgery.
Referred pain does not mean arthritis has traveled from one joint to another. It means the location where pain is perceived may differ from its source.
Could the knee have its own problem?
The hip and knee may both be symptomatic. Someone may also change how they walk because of hip pain, making a separate knee limitation more noticeable. An examination should consider the two joints together and then assess each one individually.
The history helps: Did knee pain begin before or after the hip symptoms? Does turning the hip reproduce familiar discomfort? Does the knee swell, lock, or hurt with specific knee movements? Has walking distance changed? These details help determine what needs further investigation.
Pain location alone cannot settle the diagnosis. Neither can a statement that the hip is “severe” on an X-ray.
Why the X-ray and symptoms may not match
A diagnostic study using the Framingham and Osteoarthritis Initiative cohorts found limited agreement between frequent hip pain and radiographic hip osteoarthritis. Some hips with arthritis were not frequently painful, while many painful hips did not show radiographic arthritis. The study also warned that relying only on radiographs could miss clinically suspected disease. (2)
The lesson is to combine the history, examination, and appropriate imaging. It is not that X-rays are unimportant or that arthritis cannot hurt. Imaging helps assess joint structure; the clinical assessment helps establish how those findings relate to the person’s symptoms and limitations.
Comfortable movement may be reassuring, but good range of motion alone does not rule out a joint-related source. Persistent pain needs an explanation that fits the whole presentation.
What if the pain is on the outside of the hip?
In the radio discussion, Dr. Darrow described a patient whose most prominent tenderness was around the greater trochanter, the bony area on the outside of the upper thigh. He used the account to emphasize examining tissues around the joint. The story does not establish that every person with lateral hip pain can avoid replacement or has the same diagnosis.
Lateral hip symptoms can involve the gluteal tendons and nearby bursae, often grouped under greater trochanteric pain syndrome. These problems can coexist with hip arthritis. Treatment directed at one does not necessarily address the other.
For confirmed gluteal tendinopathy, a randomized trial of 204 participants found that education about load management combined with exercise produced better global improvement than corticosteroid injection at eight and 52 weeks. At 52 weeks, pain intensity did not differ between those two groups. The findings support rehabilitation as an important option for this specific diagnosis. (3)
What does newer PRP research show for lateral hip pain?
Dr. Darrow discussed PRP and cell-based treatments from his clinical perspective. Controlled evidence needs to be considered separately.
A 2025 double-blind trial included 79 patients with persistent greater trochanteric pain and compared ultrasound-guided leukocyte-rich PRP with placebo. It did not find a significant between-group advantage for PRP at the assessed follow-ups. The investigators did not support its routine use for that condition. This trial concerns lateral hip pain associated with bursitis and/or gluteal tendinopathy, not every form of hip pain. (4)
It would therefore be misleading to promise that an injection will reliably repair all painful tissues around the hip. It would also be misleading to transfer findings from a hip-joint arthritis study to a gluteal tendon problem without explaining the difference.
Can a diagnostic injection help locate the pain?
Dr. Darrow described using local anesthetic in selected situations to investigate a suspected pain source. Temporary relief can provide supporting information when the target and response are carefully assessed. It does not independently prove a single diagnosis, demonstrate that a later regenerative treatment will work, or establish that all other causes have been excluded.
The decision to use a diagnostic injection depends on the clinical question. Sometimes examination and imaging already provide enough information; sometimes uncertainty remains and further assessment is needed.
How should treatment be chosen?
Treatment should follow the diagnosis and the patient’s functional goals. A painful arthritic hip, gluteal tendinopathy, a separate knee disorder, and referred spinal pain may require different approaches. More than one may need attention.
Before deciding on a procedure, the patient should understand which problem it is intended to address, what benefit is realistic, and what symptoms might remain. Continued pain after a treatment should lead to reassessment rather than an automatic assumption that the same treatment simply needs repeating.
Related reading: Hip osteoarthritis treatment options and greater trochanteric pain syndrome.
References
1 Dibra FF, Prieto HA, Gray CF, Parvataneni HK. Don’t forget the hip! Hip arthritis masquerading as knee pain. Arthroplast Today. 2018;4(1):118-124. doi:10.1016/j.artd.2017.06.008.
2 Kim C, Nevitt MC, Niu J, Clancy MM, Lane NE, Link TM, Vlad S, Tolstykh I, Jungmann PM, Felson DT, Guermazi A. Association of hip pain with radiographic evidence of hip osteoarthritis: diagnostic test study. BMJ. 2015;351:h5983. doi:10.1136/bmj.h5983.
3 Mellor R, Bennell K, Grimaldi A, Nicolson P, Kasza J, Hodges P, Wajswelner H, Vicenzino B. Education plus exercise versus corticosteroid injection use versus a wait and see approach on global outcome and pain from gluteal tendinopathy: prospective, single blinded, randomised clinical trial. BMJ. 2018;361:k1662. doi:10.1136/bmj.k1662.
4 Atchia I, Ali M, Oderuth E, Holleyman R, Malviya A. Efficacy of Platelet-Rich Plasma Versus Placebo for the Treatment of Greater Trochanteric Pain Syndrome: A Double-Blinded Randomized Controlled Trial. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2025;107(5):444-451. doi:10.2106/jbjs.24.00763.





