Marc Darrow, MD, JD
When neck pain travels into the shoulder, arm, or hand, an MRI can seem like the final answer. The report may describe a disc protrusion, bone spurs, or narrowing around a nerve. Those findings can matter, but identifying an abnormality is only part of identifying the cause of pain.
The useful question is whether the scan explains the symptoms: the affected side, the pattern of pain or numbness, and any changes in strength or reflexes. When these findings disagree, the next step is to investigate the discrepancy before choosing a treatment target.
What did the study of neck and arm pain find?
A 2022 study examined 83 patients with neck pain and related arm pain referred to a spine unit. Researchers compared the nerve root suspected from a clinical neurological examination with the most affected nerve root on cervical MRI. The examination and MRI identified the same side and nerve-root level in only 31% of patients. Another 28% had agreement at an adjacent level. Clinical evaluators agreed with each other in 58% of cases. (1)
These results illustrate how difficult it can be to identify the responsible nerve root. They also show why a report mentioning several abnormal levels may leave patients with questions rather than a clear explanation.
However, the study does not mean MRI is only 31% accurate. It measured agreement between clinical assessment and imaging. It did not independently establish the true pain source and then test which method identified it correctly. Neither the scan nor the examination served as an unquestionable reference standard. (1)
Why can the MRI and examination disagree?
MRI shows anatomy: discs, nerve roots, the spinal cord, and surrounding structures. It does not directly measure pain. A structural change may be relevant, incidental, or one contributor among several.
In a separate study of 78 patients with recent-onset cervical radiculopathy, MRI showed compression of the clinically affected nerve root in 73%. But 45% also had compression without corresponding clinical findings, sometimes alongside compression of the symptomatic root. Some scans appeared normal despite clinical symptoms. The authors emphasized interpreting MRI together with the examination. (2)
The examination has limitations, too. Nerve territories overlap, symptoms vary between people, and pain does not always follow the neat boundaries shown on dermatome charts. A dermatome is an area of skin supplied predominantly by a particular spinal nerve root. These maps are useful guides, but they cannot identify every patient’s problem by themselves. (1)
The studies involved different patient groups and methods, so their percentages should not be treated as interchangeable measures of accuracy.
What does a careful examination add?
A useful assessment connects the patient’s history with several findings rather than relying on the location of pain alone. Questions include:
- Does pain begin in the neck and travel down the arm, or begin around the shoulder or elbow?
- Which fingers become numb, and is that pattern consistent?
- Is there measurable weakness, a reflex change, or altered sensation?
- Do neck movements reproduce the symptoms, and do shoulder or arm movements suggest another source?
For example, right-sided arm symptoms require an explanation if the most prominent MRI finding is on the left. Similarly, several narrowed nerve openings do not establish that every level needs treatment. Agreement among the history, examination, and images increases confidence in a proposed diagnosis; disagreement lowers that confidence.
The actual images may also deserve review alongside the report, particularly when the wording does not clearly explain which nerve is affected.
Could the pain be coming from somewhere else?
Arm pain does not always originate from a cervical nerve root. Shoulder disorders, peripheral nerve entrapment at the elbow or wrist, and muscular pain can produce overlapping symptoms. More than one problem can coexist.
That is why examining only the neck can leave part of the picture unexplained. An MRI abnormality should not prevent consideration of other causes. Conversely, a shoulder diagnosis should not end the assessment when progressive weakness or other neurological changes suggest nerve involvement.
The purpose of reassessment is to identify the explanation that best fits the whole presentation.
When might additional testing help?
Electromyography and nerve-conduction studies may help when the question is whether symptoms arise from a nerve root, a peripheral nerve, or another neurological problem. These tests evaluate aspects of nerve and muscle function; MRI evaluates structure. Neither provides every answer, and a normal electrical study does not exclude every cause of radiating pain.
Ultrasound can help assess selected peripheral nerves and shoulder structures, but it does not replace cervical MRI for evaluating the spinal cord and deep spinal anatomy. Our related article discusses ultrasound versus MRI for possible nerve problems in the neck.
Additional testing is most useful when it addresses a specific unresolved question that could change management.
What does this mean for treatment?
When symptoms and imaging do not align, it is reasonable to ask: What finding supports the proposed target? What alternatives have been considered? What improvement would indicate that treatment addressed the problem?
New or worsening weakness, loss of hand coordination, walking or balance changes, or new bladder or bowel dysfunction warrant prompt medical assessment. These symptoms can raise concern about significant nerve or spinal cord involvement.
MRI remains an important tool. Its greatest value comes from interpreting it alongside the patient’s symptoms and examination, with a willingness to reconsider the diagnosis when the pieces do not fit.
References
1 Redebrandt HN, Brandt C, Hawran S, Bendix T. Clinical evaluation versus magnetic resonance imaging findings in patients with radicular arm pain—A pragmatic study. Health Science Reports. 2022;5(3):e589. doi:10.1002/hsr2.589.
2 Kuijper B, Tans JT, van der Kallen BF, Nollet F, Lycklama A Nijeholt GJ, de Visser M. Root compression on MRI compared with clinical findings in patients with recent onset cervical radiculopathy. Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery & Psychiatry. 2011;82(5):561–563. doi:10.1136/jnnp.2010.217182.





